LA failed homeless program value $60M and solely housed three folks

Simply three out of a promised 2,000 residences have been used to relocate the homeless in Nithya Raman’s failed $60 million venture to get folks off the streets.

Councilmember Raman, the chair of the Los Angeles Metropolis Council’s Housing and Homelessness Committee, launched the Time Restricted Subsidy program again in September as a cheaper various to Mayor Karen Bass’ Inside Protected Program — meant to get homeless folks into a longtime residence.

Raman’s plan was to lease and transfer homeless folks into 2,000 residences and subsidize their hire, moderately than pay for them to remain in motels or shelters.

Nevertheless, practically a 12 months after that plan was launched — with $62.6 million in taxpayer funds behind it — solely three residences are occupied.

The Metropolis Council first authorized investing within the subsidy mannequin final September as a part of its technique for complying with a court docket settlement with the Los Angeles Alliance for Human Rights.

4 months later, on January 28, the council authorized sources for a redesigned program concentrating on 2,000 households.

The total rollout started March 1.

Nevertheless, solely three items had occupants by June 25, in accordance with a July 1 presentation to Raman’s highly effective homeless committee — a damning consequence for a program Raman has campaigned to take citywide if elected Mayor.

“One family a month just isn’t an answer,” councilwoman Monica Rodriguez advised The Publish. “I’d say they’re having points with this system. It’s not working. I feel that’s what they found,” she continued.

Rodriguez says the $62.6 million subsidy rollout exposes the identical hole between guarantees and outcomes. “I feel the large distinction is discuss versus motion. [Raman] says plenty of phrases however doesn’t ship,” she mentioned.

The sluggish rollout follows one other homelessness program tied to Raman that The Publish revealed was stalled regardless of tens of millions of {dollars} in authorities funding.

A $4,011,357 state grant Raman secured to deal with harmful encampments alongside a 19-mile stretch of the Los Angeles River remained unspent practically two years after it was awarded, The Publish reported.

The cash got here from California’s Encampment Decision Fund, designed to maneuver folks out of encampments and into housing and supportive companies.

Raman’s workplace blamed administrative and contracting delays, calling it “deeply irritating when vital sources get caught in administrative and contracting processes.”

In adopting Raman’s Time Restricted Subsidy program, the council is attempting to maneuver away from the costly mannequin of utilizing motel rooms, which may value roughly $85,000 per individual per 12 months.

“That is par for the course for Los Angeles’ response to homelessness: too little, too late, and never sufficient consideration to creating certain essentially the most weak are faraway from the streets as shortly as potential,” Paul Webster, government director of the Los Angeles Alliance for Human Rights, advised The Publish.

“Nithya Raman and the mayor have been speaking about time-limited subsidies for years now. That is the entire motive we insisted on metrics and milestones. If we depend on town, we all know it’s going to be underwhelming at finest,” he added.

Raman’s workplace pushed again on the most recent figures, claiming they have been simply an “early snapshot of the redesigned TLS program.”

“Since contracts with service suppliers solely started this spring, the Metropolis will probably be monitoring this system intently to verify it strikes ahead efficiently. That’s precisely why we had the general public presentation: to catch points early,” Raman mentioned.

Raman needs LA to reduce its reliance on Mayor Karen Bass’ marquee Inside Protected motel program and steer extra homelessness {dollars} towards cheaper choices, together with time-limited subsidies and shared housing.

Inside Protected carries a far increased price ticket, however has produced much more housing placements. This system has value roughly $391 million and served 5,932 folks since its 2022 launch, in accordance with metropolis figures.

1,571 contributors have been in everlasting housing, whereas 1,752 remained in non permanent interim housing and a couple of,866 had exited as of early 2026.

“Primarily based on $62 million and three households, Inside Protected has now been made a freaking rock-bottom cut price. My recommendation to Ms. Raman is: She’s purported to make it more cost effective, not much less so — when you’re going to be vital of Inside Protected,” Rodriguez mentioned.

---

Obtain The California Publish App, observe us on social, and subscribe to our newsletters