discovered unconscious on a vessel docked on the Montauk Yacht Membership on Aug. 5, 2025. Martha Nolan / Fb
Hamptons style entrepreneur Martha Nolan-O’Slatarra was chilly to the contact, turning purple, and together with her mouth, chest and again of her head lined in blood when medics discovered her aboard a ship in Montauk, in accordance with paperwork The Submit obtained on the one-year anniversary of her demise.
The Montauk Fireplace Division affected person care document for the Irish-born 33-year-old founding father of East x East additionally famous purpling on her lips and below her nailbeds in addition to blood on the ground close to her physique.
“Boat was fairly heat however [patient] was cool to the contact with nail beds that had been purple with slight purpling round lips,” a word from the EMT report learn.
The physique “had dried blood in oral, head and chest space. No lively bleeding noticed or apparent sources of trauma. First arriving EMT famous blood probably from the again of head space when EMT positioned head to open airway and start” resuscitation efforts and administer oxygen, the report stated.
The report notes an “further male” was on the scene on the time of the cardiac arrest. That particular person, not recognized within the report, informed EMTs that he was in mattress with Nolan-O’Slatarra and referred to as 911 when he was unable to wake her up, the report said.
Boat proprietor Chris Durnan is the one particular person to have been beforehand confirmed as being on the scene and final seeing her alive.
He was reportedly noticed operating for assist down the Montauk Yacht Membership dock utterly nude at roughly midnight on Aug. 5, 2025. “Do one thing!” the bare man screamed, good Samaritans later informed The Submit.
Attorneys for Durnan informed New York Journal that he stripped down bare as a result of he was soaked in Nolan-O’Slattara’s vomit. EMTs didn’t word any vomit of their report.
The EMT report famous Nolan-O’Slatarra was unresponsive the complete time they had been on the scene.
An post-mortem commissioned by Nolan-O’Slatarra’s household revealed that solely hint quantities of cocaine had been present in her system, in accordance with the household’s lawyer. The Suffolk County Medical Examiner has not launched post-mortem outcomes.
A criminal offense scene professional who reviewed the report discovered the report’s particulars regarding.
“This factor stinks,” stated Patrick Zirpoli, a non-public investigator and retired Pennsylvania State Police corporal with greater than 20 years of expertise investigating crime scenes and homicides. “Simply by advantage of [the report], that’s an issue case.”
Zirpoli, who just isn’t related to this case, informed The Submit the scene may have been staged “to make it appear to be one thing else.”
“One thing occurred to have induced [bleeding from the mouth.] And I believe she. . . is deceased nicely earlier than the primary responders first obtained there,” Zirpoli stated.
Attorneys for Nolan-O’Slatarra’s County Carlow, Eire, household have additionally claimed that Durnan staged the scene.
“Legislation enforcement knowledgeable the household they believed the scene had been cleaned earlier than responders arrived,” Michael Bowe of Brithem LLP informed The Submit.
Nolan-O’Slatarra may have been lifeless for as much as an hour earlier than EMTs arrived, and she or he may have been the sufferer of an assault, Zirpoli theorized.
demise lawsuit towards Chris Durnan on Tuesday. @marthanolan / Instagram
“She shouldn’t be shedding physique temperature that shortly the place she’s chilly to the contact. For [EMTs] to acknowledge that — that’s chilly,” he stated.
The gumshoe forged doubt on the Suffolk County Police Division’s suggestion that Nolan-O’Slatarra died of a designer-drug overdose.
“I can’t see this being a drug overdose. There’s issues which can be indicative of a drug overdose like frothing of the mouth. It’s not going to trigger bleeding in your mouth if you happen to overdose on medication,” stated Zirpoli.
“There needs to be some form of assault or one thing.”
Nolan-O’Slattara’s household filed a $50 million wrongful demise lawsuit in Manhattan Civil Courtroom on Tuesday, alleging that Durnan induced Nolan-O’Slatarra’s demise by way of assault, negligence, and gross negligence.
Attorneys for Durnan couldn’t be reached for remark. The Suffolk County Police Division stated, “the investigation continues to be persevering with.”
