Lindsay Clancy will stay at a Massachusetts psychiatric hospital till additional discover as she awaits the destiny of her triple-murder case after a shocking mistrial on Friday.
Clancy, 36, will return to Tewksbury Hospital, the state-run facility the place she was beforehand being held, her protection lawyer Kevin Reddington confirmed on Friday after his last-ditch enchantment to stave off a mistrial was denied by the state’s Supreme Court docket.
The jury was unable to succeed in a unanimous determination — resulting from one male holdout juror — about whether or not Clancy was criminally answerable for strangling her three youngsters, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, within the basement of their Duxbury house on Jan. 24, 2023.
Clancy, who claims she was within the throes of postpartum psychosis and overprescribed a cocktail of psychiatric meds, then slit her wrists and throat and threw herself from the second story of the house, leaving her partially paralyzed.
Dr. Avram Mack, who previously labored at Nemours Kids’s Well being in Delaware, painted an image of Clancy’s dreary routine on the psychiatric facility in Tewksbury when he took the stand at her trial on Aug. 21.
“Principally, she described, she stays in mattress or on her personal,” Mack informed the courtroom, referencing interviews with Clancy on the hospital.
“I don’t assume she described interacting with sufferers very a lot. There have been a few methods through which she did work together with employees, not less than. There was a therapist that she described working with,” the shrink mentioned.
Clancy, who has to make use of a wheelchair after her suicide try, additionally labored with a bodily therapist on the hospital, however “wasn’t very ” within the bodily remedy.
“She wasn’t within the meals there,” Mack continued.
She described having guests “on a not rare foundation, and that generally, she was capable of eat meals or drinks that have been introduced in by them.”
Clancy additionally described “that she wasn’t very fascinated with her personal hygiene or grooming,” he added.
“Showering is embarrassing. It requires employees to assist her, and that’s a technique through which she would slightly not,” Mack mentioned. “It could even be that she described a scarcity of curiosity … so, it’s each parts.”
“She described feeling depressed, which she termed situational melancholy,” the psychiatrist mentioned. “She described feeling—I’m undecided the precise time period she used—however feeling depressing, not desirous to be alive.”
Mack, who bought right into a fiery alternate with Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer whereas testifying within the case, resigned from Nemours Kids’s Well being on the identical day he testified.
Clancy will stay on the facility beneath the identical homicide prices as prosecutors weigh their subsequent steps on whether or not or to not strive her once more with a brand new jury.
Her attorneys may petition for bail, although it’s seemingly she’s going to stay in Tewksbury Hospital beneath the identical bail circumstances whereas she awaits the destiny of a brand new trial, Brad Bailey, a Boston protection legal professional and former prosecutor, informed The Put up.
Bailey, who shouldn’t be concerned within the case, believes Plymouth County District Lawyer Timothy J. Cruz will push to retry Clancy following the mistrial to push for justice within the killings of little Cora, Dawson, and Callan.
“I do anticipate that Tim Cruz will select to retry the case, not solely as a result of, in his opinion, he has to face up for the three deceased kids, but in addition as a result of the case hasn’t been resolved,” Bailey mentioned.
Prosecutors could provide Clancy a plea deal for a lesser cost, equivalent to second-degree homicide or manslaughter slightly than first-degree homicide, in line with Bailey.
“I can’t think about Kevin Reddington would settle for that or take it,” Bailey added of a plea deal.
Bailey mentioned he believes that at a brand new trial, the prosecution will give attention to discovering stronger specialists, particularly ones which have expertise with treating postpartum psychosis.
The protection may even seemingly attempt to do a greater job serving to the jury perceive that sufferers can come out and in of psychosis and have durations of lucidity, the legal professional added.
Until Cruz confidently determines that it isn’t value retrying Clancy, on condition that 11-to-1 jurors are looking for to acquit her, he’s unlikely to hunt a dismissal.
“If the state decides it doesn’t need to retry, it might do what we name a nolle prosequi within the case, which is a transfer to dismiss the indictments on their very own,” Bailey mentioned.
“I believe we’re gonna be taking a look at a trial down the road, which is gonna be Homicide One, and far of the method and proceedings are gonna be the identical,” he continued.
“And I’d be shocked if he will get any totally different end result, and positively it’s probably attainable that the protection may get the end result they’re in search of.”
