BROCKTON, Massachusetts — The holdout juror who sparked a mistrial within the Lindsay Clancy homicide case didn’t permit his Catholic religion to override his judgment that the previous nurse was responsible of homicide, his brother revealed to The Submit — as he stated the household’s life has been turned up-side down.
“I don’t suppose faith had something to do with it,” the brother stated, disputing claims on-line.
The bombshell Clancy trial turned nationwide consideration to the juror, whom The Submit is selecting to not identify — with some labeling him a hero for refusing to search out Clancy not responsible, and different jurors claiming he refused to comply with the decide’s directions about “cheap doubt.”
“He seemed on the case, and he made the decision,” the brother stated. “For me, that’s how I’d do it. I’d simply take heed to the case with all of the proof, and go from there.”
He added: “His selection was good for some folks, however not good for different folks.”
However the consideration has additionally raised questions concerning the juror’s troubling legal document following a 2021 arrest for allegedly battering his then-wife over the couple’s crying toddler.
These prices have been dismissed, however in 2025 he was accused of beating the teenage nephew who known as police on him in the course of the alleged home violence assault, in keeping with courtroom information.
The juror had a restraining order towards him from the nephew on the time he was picked for the Clancy jury — and it expired in the course of the trial, courtroom paperwork reveal.
The brother additionally stated that the devoutly Catholic Haitian immigrant clan has been relentlessly hounded by true-crime gawkers and reporters for the reason that juror refused to agree with the 11 others and discover Clancy not responsible of homicide by purpose of madness after she killed her three youngsters.
“My household can not go away the home,” the brother stated.
“They’re leaving notes at my mom’s home. They received’t go away us alone and we don’t know something,” he added.
“Folks have been calling me like loopy. It’s loopy.”
Not one of the household had any thought the final week of mayhem that was headed for them after the case led to an explosive mistrial on Sept. 4 — the juror didn’t inform any of them he was serving on the headline-making case.
“We didn’t know. That’s why I used to be shocked,” the brother stated. “He didn’t inform us something.”
Clancy, 36, admitted to strangling her three youngsters — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and 8-month Callan — with train bands after which making an attempt suicide at their Duxbury house after asking her husband to depart the home on an errand.
However she claimed the killings have been pushed by a months-long wrestle with excessive postpartum psychosis, which she claims was misdiagnosed and never correctly handled by medical doctors.
Jurors deliberated for practically per week, with 11 of the 12 taking Clancy’s facet — however the holdout refused to budge.
A supporter launched a GiveSendGo fundraiser for the juror on Monday, which introduced in practically $190,000 in a matter of hours.
Claims concerning the juror’s non secular beliefs over-riding the decide’s directions have been fueled by feedback from prosecutors and their witnesses that explicitly invoked the Catholic thought of “mortal sin” of homicide and suicide in the course of the trial — drawing rebukes from the decide.
Potential jurors are required to reveal whether or not they had ever been arrested, charged with against the law or been served a courtroom order — pertinent disclosures for this explicit juror with a historical past of home allegations, because the Clancy case concerned essentially the most extreme type of home violence.
It’s not clear how the juror answered these questions.
After the juror’s 2021 home violence arrest, his personal mom yelled “You’re evil” whereas he was hauled away, in keeping with courtroom docs.
Expenses over the incident have been later dismissed and the juror divorced his spouse, who advised NBC Boston she didn’t wish to testify for concern of dropping custody of her little one.
The ex-wife, who posed for a photograph with Boston Mayor Michelle Wu after finishing an English language program and enrolling in neighborhood faculty, is learning to change into a nurse, one neighbor advised The Submit.
Her household stated that they’re fearful of the juror.
However in 2025 extra allegations arose towards the juror after he allegedly attacked the identical nephew who known as police — with the juror shoving the teenager to the bottom and hitting him within the face, in keeping with a restraining order.
“You ruined my [expletive] life,” the juror reportedly yelled on the teen, in keeping with an affidavit. “You’ve had this coming your approach for a very long time.”
However others within the juror’s life noticed him as a church-going man who was beneficiant.
“He’s a very nice man,” stated the proprietor of a neighborhood storage the place the juror takes his automotive for repairs and frequently fuels up. “He goes to church.”
“He paid for a girl the opposite day who couldn’t pay her fuel,” the enterprise proprietor added. “She stated, ‘I can’t pay.’ And he went proper over and paid her invoice.”
And the mechanic store boss wasn’t stunned to hear his buyer was the holdout juror who refused to search out Clancy not responsible by purpose of madness.
He stated the household has now gone into hiding.
“His spouse — they only bought married — got here by yesterday and requested me to place new wheels on her automotive,” the proprietor stated.
“She stated the media has been loopy and so they’re gonna lay low for some time.”
