“Hell on wheels” killer Mackenzie Shirilla is nothing just like the remorseful, hardened jail inmate depicted within the hit Netflix doc, a former inmate stated.
“When she walked out within the documentary my jaw actually dropped, as a result of her demeanor and the way in which that she seemed was nothing just like the particular person I used to be in there with,” Mary Katherine Crowder, who served time with Shirilla at Ohio Reformatory for Girls, advised The Submit.
As a substitute, the 21-year-old convicted killer glammed herself up behind bars — and pranced round just like the queen bee of “Imply Women,” Crowder stated.
She additionally wasted no time getting busy — and would typically sport hickeys from hooking up with different ladies, the previous jail inmate claimed.
Shirilla’s mother and father and sugar daddies she has lured on-line assist pay for make-up and cute matches, she added.
“The Crash” — which paperwork the case of Shirilla deliberately crashing her automotive and killing her boyfriend and good friend in 2022 — has risen to No. 1 on the streaming service platform because it was launched Friday.
Shirilla, now 21, seems within the documentary from behind bars — the place she expresses regret for the deadly crash and insists she’s “not a monster.”
However the particular person portrayed there’s a far cry from the “little highschool lady” who Crowder, 27, obtained to know whereas inside jail for greater than six months in 2024, she stated.
“Once I was in there together with her, you’d have a look at her and she or he had her make-up executed each day, she was very nicely put collectively — nearly like preppy,” Crowder stated.
“However within the documentary, she didn’t appear to be that in any respect — she nearly seemed like she was conforming to the individuals which were there for some time.
“Even the way in which she talks is totally totally different — she talked like a valley lady after I was in there together with her. Her voice was very happy-go-lucky and high-pitched, however now she has an edge to her voice,” the previous inmate recalled.
She added: “This character within the documentary is nothing like who I noticed in there in any respect, and it was stunning.”
When Crowder was booked into the Ohio ladies’s jail on excellent misdemeanor warrants from Tennessee in April 2024, she observed that Shirilla — who had been within the facility for nearly eight months at that time — fancied herself a jail celeb.
“Everybody knew why she was there, and she or he walked round like she was this well-known particular person inside jail,” Crowder stated. “She all the time had make-up executed, hair executed, her garments have been altered to suit her physique tighter or be totally different.
“She undoubtedly carried herself like she was the Regina George of jail … she was very very similar to an ‘It lady’” she recalled — referencing the “Imply Women” clique chief.
Crowder, who first posted about her historical past with Shirilla in a now-viral sequence of TikTok movies earlier this week, claimed in a single clip that the teenager convict handled the clink “like a highschool reputation contest.”
And as an alternative of grieving her pals “each single day,” as she claimed within the new Netflix particular, Shirilla spent her days “principally skipping” across the jail yard with a tight-knit group of younger inmates, in keeping with Crowder.
“She was all the time laughing, all the time smiling and blissful — prefer it was by no means on her thoughts that she was serving two concurrent 15-to-life sentences as a result of she killed two individuals,” Crowder stated — including that Shirilla would promote personalized jewellery and footwear to different inmates contained in the jail.
“By no means one time did I see Mackenzie cry,” the previous inmate additional claimed in a single TikTok video that amassed practically 20 million views.
“She walked round like she thinks she’s gonna get out.”
Shirilla additionally cycled by way of a number of romantic relationships with different feminine inmates, Crowder claimed within the social media clips.
“Sure, Mackenzie has had a number of girlfriends … she was strolling round with hickies on her neck,” she stated in a single video.
“She’s gone to ‘the outlet’ for being intimate with women in jail.
“If she was grieving or remorseful, she wouldn’t have gone to jail and jumped into jail relationships over the following six months,” Crowder continued.
Shirilla — whose four-year relationship with Dominic Russo had devolved into intense toxicity within the weeks main as much as the crash that killed him, in keeping with prosecutors — was financially supported by her mother and father and different exterior supporters inside jail,
She acquired new garments, make-up and different commissary perks ordered by way of third-party distributors, Crowder claimed.
“Mackenzie has make-up and jewellery in jail as a result of her mother is ordering it for her … she was funding her jail way of life and making it as snug as potential,” she stated in a TikTok clip. “She’s privileged in jail as a result of her mom and father allow that.
“Additionally, Mackenzie is on the … jail sugar daddy web site, so there’s sugar daddies, like, supplying her wants,” Crowder claimed.
The TikToker additionally confirmed wild pictures of Shirilla posing and exhibiting off a brand new outfit in tone-deaf selfie photos taken with prison-issued, iPad-like tablets.
“The Mackenzie that I used to be in there with seemed a bit bit extra like this,” Crowder stated in entrance of a picture of Shirilla pursing her lips whereas sporting a pink t-shirt and purple-and-pink hair clips.
“Very bright-faced, very girly.”
The video then pans to point out Shirilla posing whereas posing in an outsized navy blue high and a slick-back bun — in a photograph “exhibiting her outfit that she obtained custom-made in jail,” the previous inmate stated.
Crowder additionally solid doubt on claims raised within the documentary surrounding Shirilla’s well being and model of occasions main as much as the lethal crash, saying she by no means noticed her searching for medical therapy behind bars.
“By no means one time did I ever see Mackenzie Shirilla go for a blood strain verify, take any kind of treatment or go to sick name, ever expertise dizziness.
“In actual fact, Mackenzie Shirilla would exit in 100-degree heatwaves with child oil on her and sit within the jail yard and tan … the lady doesn’t have any medical points,” Crowder claimed.
Shirilla additionally advised a vastly totally different story to her jail pals than the one painted by prosecutors utilizing blood check outcomes from the evening of the crash — which confirmed that the teenager killer solely had THC in her system throughout the grisly occasion.
“Mackenzie’s story after I was in jail together with her was that she was excessive on shrooms when this accident occurred,” Crowder stated.
The previous inmate blasted the Netflix documentary for “attempting to painting her as this harmless, well-behaved suburban lady.
“That’s not what she’s ever been or who she’s ever been,” she fumed.
Shirilla’s lawyer didn’t instantly reply to inquiries.
